Category talk:Non-collector trophies

Rename?

This category is misleading. I'd rather think of trophies that are not collector trophies that is found as loot from monsters, not monster loot trophies which do not have collectors —ZerphaThe Improver 23:36, 26 April 2008 (UTC)

Nicholas Items?

Would it be appropriate to remove items that Nicholas accepts, such as Mursaat Tokens? Gwynna Vive 10:06, 23 December 2012 (UTC)

I think they should remain in this category. This category also contains trophies that are only collected during special events (e.g. Canthan New Year), which occur annually on a pre-set date, while Nicholas the Traveler collects items in a random order within a 137 week cycle. So you could keep any Fiery Crests, Igneous Spider Legs, Iridescent Griffon Wings or Smoking Remains in your inventory or storage knowing that there will be collectors for them when the next Canthan New Year finale occurs in January or February, but you have no idea in the next two and a half years when Nicholas will collect Gloom Seeds, Mursaat Tokens or Phantom Residues. --Silver Edge 21:57, 23 December 2012 (UTC)

Previous commentary is outdated: now all Nicholas' items are known as well as his schedule. So, it would have sense to exclude those items from this category, and items for Canthan New Year too. Or, alternatively, to add another category for the items which don't have any collector at all, regular or events-tied. For example, it can be called "Trash items" (maybe not the best name because in other MMOs this is often associated with grey-quality items which don't exist in Guild Wars). --109.252.109.37 22:14, 13 August 2018 (UTC)